Do expensive wines taste better? What 6,175 blind tastings found

Do expensive wines taste better? What 6,175 blind tastings found

The Debate. Debate No. 3.

Blind, people without wine training rated the pricier wines slightly lower

Economists pooled 6,175 blind tastings of 523 wines, priced from US$1.65 to US$150 a bottle. 506 people rated each wine Bad, Okay, Good or Great. About 12% of them had wine training.

When the price rose tenfold, tasters without training rated the wine about four points lower on a 100-point scale. Trained tasters rated it about seven points higher, a marginal result that falls short of the usual test of statistical significance.

TastersPrice ten times higherNote
No wine trainingAbout 4 points lowerMost of the sample
Wine trainingAbout 7 points higherMarginal result

The case for price comes from the other direction. When drinkers can see the price, it changes how much they enjoy the wine: see the $90 label study.

Blind, would you pick the $150 bottle?

The plate

Plate reading: Do expensive wines taste better? Blind, the answer changes, with an engraving of two bottles in paper bags beside empty glasses.
6,175 blind tastings. Economists pooled blind tastings of 523 wines, priced from $1.65 to $150 a bottle, rated Bad, Okay, Good or Great by 506 people.
When the price rose tenfold. Non-experts: minus 4 points. Trained tasters: plus 7 points, a marginal result. About 12% of tasters had wine training. Goldstein et al., Journal of Wine Economics, 2008.
The case for price. A brain-scanner study found the same wine rated more pleasant at $90 than at $10, with more activity in the brain's reward region. Plassmann et al., PNAS, 2008.
The case against. In the blind tastings, non-experts enjoyed the cheaper bottles slightly more. Only trained tasters leaned the other way, and only just.
Blind, would you pick the $150 bottle? Yes, every time. Not a chance. Pass it on: send it to the friend who insists they can tell.

Sources

  • Goldstein R, Almenberg J, Dreber A, Emerson JW, Herschkowitsch A, Katz J. “Do More Expensive Wines Taste Better? Evidence from a Large Sample of Blind Tastings.” Journal of Wine Economics 2008;3(1):1–9: goldstein.faculty.ucdavis.edu
  • American Association of Wine Economists working paper version: ageconsearch.umn.edu

All wine plates

Book a tableGift cards